Info
Info

AMEC Wins Injunction In Patent Infringement Dispute

 

Advanced Micro-Fabrication Equipment (AMEC) announced that the Fujian High Court in China has granted AMEC's motion for an injunction against Veeco Instruments (Shanghai) Co. Ltd. (Veeco Shanghai). The injunction prohibits Veeco Shanghai from importing, manufacturing, selling or offering for sale to any third party any MOCVD systems and wafer carriers used in the MOCVD systems that would infringe AMEC's patent CN 202492576 in China. The patent covers AMEC's proprietary wafer carrier and spindle-locking and synchronization technology. The injunction covers Veeco's TurboDisk EPIK 700 system, EPIK 700 C2 system, and EPIK 700 C4 system, as well as the related wafer carriers used in the MOCVD systems. AMEC believes that the ruling should also cover Veeco's EPIK 868 system and related wafer carriers, since AMEC believes that the EPIK 868 system also uses AMEC's patented technology involved in the action.

The ruling, which can not be appealed, takes effect immediately. The stringent injunction terms expose the nature of Veeco Shanghai's flagrant violation of AMEC's intellectual property (IP) and confirms that Veeco Shanghai does not respect AMEC's IP rights.

AMEC filed the patent infringement claim against Veeco Shanghai in the Fujian High Court on July 13th 2017. The motion requested a permanent injunction against Veeco Shanghai, as well as compensation for monetary damages of more than 100 million RMB Yuan (approx. US$15 million).

The injunction follows a previous victory for AMEC relating to the same action. When AMEC filed its claim in July, Veeco Shanghai responded by filing a patent invalidation request with the Patent Re-examination Board (PRB) of the State Intellectual Property Office (SIPO) in China. A second request to invalidate the same AMEC patent was filed concurrently by an individual. The PRB held separate hearings for the two requests. On Nov. 24th 2017, the PRB dismissed both requests, thereby upholding the validity of the patent.

AMEC invested heavily in R&D and IP protection for this key technology. AMEC first developed the technology, filed a series of patents to protect the innovations, and installed equipment containing the technology at a number of LED production fabs in China. Veeco later followed by using the same locking approach in its MOCVD system to improve the tool's performance. After AMEC filed the patent disputed by Veeco Shanghai, Veeco Instruments Inc. (Veeco US) submitted a similar patent application, and subsequently used this technology in its MOCVD system, thus infringing AMEC's patent.

"The court's ruling and the PRB's decisions together confirm in no uncertain terms that AMEC's technology contains unique innovations, and that our patent portfolio is comprehensive, robust and highly valuable," said Dr. Zhiyou Du, Senior Vice President, COO & General Manager of AMEC's MOCVD Product Division. "We are very pleased with the court's decision. We take IP enforcement seriously, and we will not tolerate any violation of our IP rights. Indeed, we will aggressively pursue instances of infringement, and vigorously protect our IP portfolio."

Dr. Du continued: "As a supplier of high-end micro-fabrication equipment to leading global manufacturers of ICs, LEDs and power devices, AMEC attaches great importance to IP protection. Since our founding in 2004, we have independently developed unique technologies to enable our customers worldwide. Therefore, for more than a decade, we have defended our IP in domestic and international jurisdictions when challenged, and prevailed in every case. We respect the IP of our customers and competitors, and we expect the same regard for our IP."

In a separate development, AMEC filed a motion on Dec. 8th 2017 to invalidate a Veeco patent with the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) of the US Patent & Trademark Office (USPTO). The patent, US 6,726,769 filed in 2001, covers a detachable wafer carrier technology. It was asserted in an infringement action initiated in the US by Veeco US against AMEC's supplier of wafer carriers for MOCVD systems. AMEC believes that the Veeco patent is invalid because the technology was definitively and clearly disclosed in many prior patents and publications as far back as the early 1960s. Therefore, the Veeco patent does not meet standard patent law requirements. Besides filing to invalidate the patent in the US, AMEC has already filed motions to invalidate counterpart patent families in China and South Korea.

AMEC intends to also challenge a second Veeco US patent (US 6,506,252) involved in the same US infringement action. A motion to that effect will soon be filed with the PTAB.

Dr. Gerald Yin, Chairman and CEO of AMEC, said: "We are confident that AMEC will prevail in its action against Veeco Shanghai, and that Veeco Shanghai will be required to pay for the enormous cost of its infringement beginning in 2014 when Veeco US launched its EPIK 700 system. In addition, we believe that our supplier will eventually prevail in its US case."

Dr. Yin further noted: "AMEC is an innovative company with extensive expertise in providing breakthrough technologies that enable customers with competitive advantages. Our products have earned market success for their differentiation and value. Naturally, we prefer to focus our efforts on providing such innovative products and stellar service to customers instead of wasting time and resources on litigation. That's why we're fully committed to reaching a positive resolution with Veeco, and working diligently to achieve that goal."

Brewer Science Announces RDL-first Fan-out Packaging Material
Infineon Adds 200 V Half-bridge Gate Driver IC For Reliable Start-up Operation
Healthcare Transformation: A Business Opportunity For BioMEMS
GLOBALFOUNDRIES Reshapes Technology Portfolio To Focus On Differentiated Offerings
NanoScientific Symposium On Scanning Probe Microscopy (SPM)
Helium Leak Detector Solutions
NXP Acquires OmniPHY To Accelerate Autonomous Driving And Vehicle Networks
Infineon Expands U.S.-based IoT Security Research And Development Programs
Chroma Offers Semiconductor Test Solutions
UGent And Imec Launch Fiber Optic Sensing Spin-off Sentea
Murata Invests In MEMS Sensor Manufacturing
SiTime And Bosch Accelerate Innovation In MEMS Timing For 5G And IoT
Imec.xpand Raises EUR 117 Million To Invest In Innovative, Early-stage Ideas
New Material Could Improve Efficiency Of Computer Processing And Memory
China’s Semiconductor Fab Capacity To Reach 20 Percent Worldwide Share In 2020
Nova's Materials Metrology Solution Selected For 5nm Technology Node
Sensirion Announce Strong Revenue Growth In First Half-year 2018
Teledyne E2v’s Emerald 12M And 16M Image Sensors Enter Mass Production
Rudolph Technologies Launches Second-gen Inspection And Metrology System
Himax Technologies Rebukes Motley Fool Article
Palomar Technologies Awarded ISO 9001:2015 Certificate
Thermco Systems Expands Global Operations With Acquisition Of CSD Epitaxy
VTT Is Ranked Fourth In The World's Largest Research Funding Programme
KLA-Tencor Expands IC Packaging Portfolio

Info
×
Search the news archive

To close this popup you can press escape or click the close icon.
Logo
×
Logo
×
Register - Step 1

You may choose to subscribe to the Silicon Semiconductor Magazine, the Silicon Semiconductor Newsletter, or both. You may also request additional information if required, before submitting your application.


Please subscribe me to:

 

You chose the industry type of "Other"

Please enter the industry that you work in:
Please enter the industry that you work in:
 
X
Info
X
Info